Putin needs to understand that the war in Ukraine is untenable - The Globe and Mail
SUBSCRIBE FROM $0.99/WEEK
**Find clarity in the chaos.** Subscribe now and save 70%
Digital accessDigital + home delivery
SUBSCRIBE FROM $0.99/WEEK
Invest in your team with The Globe Professional: a digital group subscription
Putin needs to understand that the war in Ukraine is untenable
SUBSCRIBE FROM $0.99/WEEK
opinion
Putin needs to understand that the war in Ukraine is untenable
Amy Knight
Special to The Globe and Mail
Published 13 hours ago
Open this photo in gallery:
*A woman looks out of a window of a damaged residential building in the Moscow region hit by what authorities described as a Ukrainian drone strike on Sept. 20.Stringer/Reuters*
Comments
Please log in to bookmark this story.Log InCreate an account
Listen to this article
Learn more about audio
Log in or Create an account to listen to this article.
*Amy Knight’s most recent book is* The Kremlin’s Noose: Putin’s Bitter Feud With The Oligarch Who Made Him Ruler of Russia.
The new round of U.S.-mediated peace negotiations between Ukraine and Russia, scheduled to begin in Abu Dhabi on Tuesday, is unlikely to make significant progress. Not only are Kyiv and Vladimir Putin’s government far apart on key territorial issues and postwar security guarantees, but the Russian delegation is headed by Vladimir Medinsky, a firebrand Kremlin propagandist who has led past peace talks and made unacceptable demands. As Russian journalist Andrei Kolesnikov observed: “With Medinsky leading the delegation, the talks will go nowhere. His appointment as head of the delegation was already a signal from Putin: ‘Guys, our position isn’t changing.’”
Dangling the prospect of sanctions relief and business deals will not persuade Mr. Putin to reach a viable peace deal with Ukraine. He must instead face consequences that make continuing the war untenable for Russia.
Those consequences have already been mounting. A recent data leak from Rosstat, the Russian state statistics agency, revealed that 450,000 Russians have been killed since the war began. The country’s combat casualties are increasing so rapidly that recruitment of conscripts can no longer keep pace. Mr. Putin lacks the political capital for mass mobilization, so the regime has resorted to arresting men on flimsy charges and forcing them to sign military contracts. In the words of Russian commentator Maxim Katz, “the state is grinding through people at the front so quickly that its need for more will only grow and the methods of coercion will only become harsher.”
For all this horrific bloodletting, Russian forces actually lost around 27 square kilometres of territory on the battlefield in October. In addition, daily damage from Ukrainian strikes on factories, warehouses and refineries has cost billions of rubles. “If you look at the actual figures – the deaths, the destruction, the economic damage – then 2022, when we all lived in a state of constant horror, looks almost like a pre-war year from today’s perspective,” said Mr. Katz. “The death toll was a fraction of what it is now. Nobody was talking about oil refineries burning thousands of kilometres from the border.”
Russia pounds power facilities around Kyiv as temperatures plunge
The Kremlin is spending more than a trillion rubles a month on the war, and 17 trillion rubles have been allocated for defence in 2027. Although the Russian State Duma just approved the draft federal budget for 2027, which allows the government to collect an additional 1.5-trillion rubles in taxes from citizens and businesses next year, this will hardly be enough to prevent continued cuts in budgets for health care, education and business development.
Significantly, concerns about the budgetary shortfalls are now being expressed openly in the heavily censored Russian press. An editorial in Nezavisimaya Gazeta last month noted that, while the federal budget was meeting defence demands with tax hikes and tariffs, “mantras about the budget being sufficient to cover both defence needs and societal obligations serve only to defer any real reflection until the next budgetary cycle.”
The paper reported later that housing affordability in Russia was drastically declining: “Today, many Russians do not even have a room of their own. The deterioration of the housing stock and the number of dilapidated or unsafe residential buildings continue to grow.”
Meanwhile, high interest rates are preventing Russian companies from obtaining loans, while Western sanctions rule out raising capital from abroad. With the added challenges of rising costs, weakening domestic demand, higher taxes and shrinking profits, companies are freezing investment projects.
Russia, Ukraine exchange air strikes as U.S. envoy hails renewed security talks
Mr. Putin and his advisers doubtless realize that, with state resources stretched thin and the pool of potential combatants shrinking, sooner or later they will have to negotiate a peace settlement.
But ending the conflict without achieving all of Moscow’s declared aims has perils for Mr. Putin. As Russian political scientist Abbas Gallyamov recently pointed out, the huge casualties can be justified as a necessary price for gaining ultimate victory, but “if the war ends without a clear victory, an unavoidable question will arise: What did they die for?”
Mr. Putin needs to be persuaded that the negative consequences of continuing the war outweigh the risks of concluding it. That would require the U.S. to stand firmly with Ukraine’s European allies, making it clear to the Russian President that Washington and Europe will provide Ukraine with everything necessary to defeat Russia on the battlefield, defend itself against Russia’s drones and missiles, and continue to wreak havoc on Russia’s economy with air strikes against its energy and technological infrastructure. Faced with that prospect, Mr. Putin might be forced to conclude that he has no choice but to agree to a peace deal that is acceptable to Ukraine.
Sign up for the Opinion Newsletter.
Keep your opinions sharp and informed with a helpful summary of The Globe’s most provocative columns, covering politics, world affairs, business, arts, health and the way we live
Explore newsletters
Report an editorial error
Report a technical issue
Editorial code of conduct
Diversions
Horoscope
Daily astrology with Sally Brompton
Daily Crossword
Solve today's puzzle
Daily Cryptic
Witty word play at its best
Sudoku
Three difficulty levels to solve
Follow related authors and topics
Authors and topics you follow will be added to your personal news feed in Following.
Interact with The Globe
Real Estate newsletter
Stay on top of the housing market
Your house is your most valuable asset. Read about the latest closing sales, house market trends, mortgages and more
Sign up
life and culture
Meet Erin Anderssen
Follow Erin Anderssen, The Globe's happiness reporter, as she uncovers the secrets and science to living a happier, more fulfilling life.
Learn more
Tools and calculators
Make confident decisions
Our financial tools and calculators can help you take on whatever life throws your way
start now
Connect with The Globe
Share news tips anonymously
Use SecureDrop to share information with The Globe’s investigative team with more security and anonymity than traditional means
Learn more
Interact with The Globe
* !Erin Anderssen
life and culture
Meet Erin Anderssen
Follow Erin Anderssen, The Globe's happiness reporter, as she uncovers the sec
Opinion: Putin needs to understand that the war in Ukraine is untenable - The Globe and Mail
Writing in The Globe and Mail, Amy Knight argues that offering Putin sanctions relief and business deals will not produce a viable peace, and that Russia must instead face consequences that make continuing the war untenable. She points to mounting casualties and growing economic and budgetary strain inside Russia, and urges Washington to stand firmly with Ukraine's European allies.
Cross Lines newsroom
Share this article
#روسيا#أوكرانيا#بوتين#مفاوضات أبوظبي#العقوبات#الاقتصاد الروسي
Original source: أخبار روسيا


